Former Premier Soccer League (PSL) referee Victor Hlungwani has expressed his disapproval over the officiating in the recent Kaizer Chiefs vs. Mamelodi Sundowns clash, particularly regarding the bizarre decision to send off an iPad from the Chiefs' technical area. The incident unfolded after Sundowns' second goal, which was controversial due to a potential offside in the build-up.
The goal triggered an uproar on the Kaizer Chiefs bench, with the team reviewing the incident on their iPad. Displeased with what they saw, they remonstrated with the match officials, believing the goal should have been ruled out.
The confrontation escalated, prompting referee Sikhumbuzo Gasa to issue a red card. However, instead of dismissing a member of the Chiefs' technical staff, Gasa sent off the iPad itself—a decision that left many scratching their heads.
Hlungwani, speaking on Soccerzone, weighed in on the situation, asserting that the officials made a mistake. While he agreed that the offside decision was correctly handled, he emphasized that the red card should have been directed at an individual, not a piece of equipment.
“We saw a gadget given a red card," Hlungwani remarked. "Now, what does the law say? The law says gadgets are allowed. But this gadget was given a red card. I don’t know why."
The FIFA laws of the game permit the use of electronic communication devices by technical staff during matches. These devices can be used for tactical and analytical purposes.
However, if the device leads to inappropriate behavior or is used improperly, it is the individual responsible who should face consequences—not the equipment itself.
He concluded that the referees had misapplied the laws of the game. "Someone should’ve been sent off, not the equipment. Incorrect application of the laws of the game by the match officials," he said.
The incident has drawn widespread attention, with many calling for improved officiating standards, particularly in handling unique situations. Chiefs ultimately lost the match 2-1, but the debate surrounding the iPad incident continues to dominate headlines